Showing posts with label feminist. Show all posts
Showing posts with label feminist. Show all posts

29 November 2015

A song of praise for Carys Bray

Song-For-Issy-Bradley-Carys-Bray

The third and final in a series of articles on the novels shortlisted for the 2015 Desmond Elliott Prize discusses A Song For Issy Bradley, written by my now-Twitter-pal Carys Bray. Spoilers as always.

I picked up Bray’s novel in a library. My first library book since university, I stared at the cover and decided to read a few chapters before I checked it out and made any real commitment. 

Instantly I knew this was a very different book to the other two shortlisters I’d reviewed. The content was drastically different. It was less female-centric, for starters, and it was going to teach me about something I really had very little grounding in before. The Mormon faith.

The religion and its practices almost take on a character of itself in the novel. You see how it behaves and what its features are, how it affects people – whether it’s a hero or an anti-hero is open to interpretation. Does it save or capture? Who can tell?

The thing that shone through in this novel is the first-hand experience of it all. The fears, experiences and thought-process all seem to come from a very real place. So when the worst happens, my grief to what was a fictional event, felt very, very real. And when expressing that fact on twitter, I got a very real response from the woman responsible.

Song-For-Issy-Bradley-Carys-Bray

Great community spirit Carys. 

What I liked so much about this was how I really wanted these characters to be OK. I didn’t feel particularly strongly that I liked or didn’t like any of them, I just felt the human will of community driving my wish that they’d be OK, they’d make it through their grief and their heartbreak and they’d be a family again. And, more than that, how I was fascinated by how they dealt with it in terms of their faith.

I finished Bray’s the quickest out of all the Desmond Elliot shortlisters, and that stands as a testament to how much I enjoyed it. Touchingly sensitive and emotionally compelling, A Song For Issy Bradly was my favourite of all three.


22 November 2015

Claire Fuller's endless enrichment of female character


The second in a series of articles on the novels shortlisted for the 2015 Desmond Elliott Prize discusses another debut, Claire Fuller's award winning Our Endless Numbered Days. Spoilers as always.

The story of my connection with Our Endless Numbered Days begins in June 2014, eight months before it's UK launch. That month, I received an email inviting me to a job interview, which I aced, accepted the job, and began working. The woman who emailed me was on holiday when I started the position, but two weeks later I met the person who originally vetted my application – Claire Fuller.

Which puts me in a rather unique position, one which I haven't been in before when talking about, well, anything. But, if my literature degree taught me anything, it's that the author doesn't really have much impact on a book. Except the writing part, of course.

Our Endless Numbered Days: title inspired by an obscure band's album (how very Winchester), winner of the 2015 Desmond Elliott Prize, and dramatic, genre-bordering thriller.

Quick plot summary: when Peggy is eight, her father – essentially – abducts her, taking her to an abandoned Hütte in the middle of absolute nowhere, or somewhere in Europe, as far as we can tell.

The novel is told entirely from Peggy's point of view, firstly from her eight year old self, up until she's 17. And for me, this is what I found most gripping.

Firstly, I like to think that Fuller (can I call her Claire? I know her as Claire) Claire chose her protagonist's gender based on more than personal experience. Take a moment to imagine if the abducted child was a boy.

The differences aren't vast at first – male and female eight year olds are quite similar in their physical and behavioural development – but I wonder if the father would even have taken a boy? Boys aren't as vulnerable as girls, or as delicate. With a female protagonist, she can remain under her father's rule no matter what. He will always be physically superior. With a male protagonist, he will eventually grow stronger and become an alpha. No matter the bond, a boy is far more likely to dominate eventually. And, if it was a boy, the ending would be very different.

Secondly, the development of the character would have taken a different turn indeed. Let's not forget, Peggy is in the woods during the most intimate physical development of her life – puberty. As a female reader – who's a practical thinker even in the most fictional of times – I couldn't help but think of questions like, what happens when Peggy gets her first period? Foliage sanitary towels?!

In this sense, readers are a lot closer to her sheer vulnerability and the extent of how feral her father has forced her to be. It's a far more impactful passage to read rather than a sentence about an awkward morning boner.

And finally, let's talk hair. Well, by that I mean enforced standards of beauty in the Western world.

Claire really effectively paints a portrait of the importance of beauty standards through what Peggy has missed out on. When she returns home, choosing clothes is a subject which absolutely baffles her. Peggy doesn't have any idea about beauty or about all these standards for women, because she hasn't learnt them. She hasn't needed to know how to brush her hair to survive, or how to accessorise. They weren't skills which would keep her alive throughout cold winters. In fact, they're entirely unnecessary. But only when she's in the Western world that she's subjected to comments on her appearance. There's a lot of this kind of comment on YA fiction at the moment, just take a look at The Hunger Games. In fact, I'd like to think Peggy and Katniss could be friends.

It's really refreshing to tear into a novel which so breaks the convention of women, especially young women, in literature. And following Peggy's development is more than fascinating, it's a complete breath of fresh air to see her emotional, mental and physical progression in such a unique environment. Despite the novel's self-limited environment, number of characters and subject matter, Peggy's character is so rich and unique, it's no wonder it won the Desmond Elliott Prize.

My copy looks like this. Yes it's signed. Yes, I went to the book launch. #humblebrag
Read my opinion of other representations of women in competitor for the prize, Emma Healey's Elizabeth is Missing.

14 October 2015

Elizabeth is Missing; or just prone to the female condition



The first in a series of articles on the novels shortlisted for the 2015 Desmond Elliott Prize begins with Emma Healey's debut bestseller, the wonderfully acclaimed Elizabeth is Missing. Spoilers as always.

Praise for Emma Healey is exactly right. Like everyone says, for her to so intricately imagine, and write, from the perspective of an elderly woman with advancing dementia is incredible. And frightening.

To reach out to an audience of younger people who are increasingly frustrated and fearful of the elderly and becoming old, and make them see the other side in such a plain way is really something special. And is doubtlessly the most fascinating and important thing to take away from Elizabeth is Missing.

When it comes to plot, it isn't necessarily the most complicated but how can it be when the protagonist can't remember her own name? I regret to say that the endings are a little more predictable than I would've liked, however maybe this is intentional, there's a good chance Maud has known all along about the fate of the missing women.

Which brings me onto my next point. Missing women. Healey seems to really shine a light on female vulnerability in this novel, in so many ways. Portrayals of vulnerable youth, elderly, mental, physical, social situation.

Healey demonstrates how women are prone to physical decay, mental trauma, and even death. In fact, three women die in the novel, one presumably at the hand of her husband, one of physical health and another knocked down in the street – each death centre to the plot. Considering that women are supposed to live longer than men, this seems like a lot.

But then again, Healey presents a very female-centric world, with the main character's immediate family consisting mostly of women. Women are represented as the centre of the family, dutifully bound to look after their mothers, sisters, daughters, whether they like it or not. While the men seem to leave and live as they please, disobeying the law, migrating to other countries, dying of old age, etc. It's a world that doesn't seem fair, and yet it seems accurate – so it's hardly going to be the feel-good novel of the year.

It's not that the men are ever portrayed as evil, or the women even particularly downtrodden, it's just a saddening portrayal of the human condition. It's sad to see Maud as a young girl while the reader knows she can barely remember her identity in the present. It's sad to see Helen struggling with caring for her while still trying  – singlehandedly  – to raise a family of her own. And it's sad that this exact scenario is happening to so many families as I type.

It's easy to see why Healey's debut became a bestseller. It's relation to crime fiction, readability and portrayal of dementia is at times comic and always heartwarmingly charming. It challenges first-person narration in a topical light and for that I would recommend it to anyone having to deal with dementia – in any shape or form. So let me try and forget that this novel reinforces the vulnerability of women, because that's not the point. Right?

02 October 2015

A woman wild


Growing up on novels with names like Housewife Down, The Playground Mafia, novels which may as well be entitled 'Domesticated', imagine my delight when I was so aptly gifted a female writer, female protagonist, true-story named Wild.

Disclaimer: this is not going to be an onslaught of feminist praise for Strayed, although I could very easily write this like that, but this will include spoilers – so if you haven't read the novel, or watched the film, proceed with caution.

The novel came into my hands by way of a friend who picked it up from a 'leave one take one' shelf in a Croatian hostel. The copy, distinctly American, sports an Oprah Book Club sticker, so by the time it reached my hands, back in a small town in England, even I felt like the book had taken its own title too seriously.

Firstly, I am cautious about addressing it as a "novel". It's been called a 'memoir' to agree with the ever-stricter genre conventions, but I'd rather call it an experience.

For the first time in a long time, I found I couldn't put a book down.

Cheryl's adventure is something anyone who's gone through a great loss, hard time, or a seriously long-ass walk, can appreciate. It's not a journey of one woman, it's the journey of anyone who's ever felt alone.

From the very beginning, and throughout the text, Strayed repeatedly returns to the concept of 'a woman alone'. She is abandoned by her father, left by her siblings, divorced by her husband and, the catalyst of it all, orphaned by her mother. She is a very literal stray. And, after being beaten down by her situation, she does everything in her power to take that appellation back.

I could write an essay on why it is important that Cheryl picks her last name. But who has time for that? The important point is that, by calling herself 'Strayed' she owns the term. It cannot be used against her, instead it defines the positive qualities of 'a woman alone'. It might not have been wholly her choice to become an orphan or a divorcee, but it was her choice to become 'Strayed'. It signifies her independence, individuality, and is more than fitting for her adventure across the country.

Which means it also counteracts any vulnerability associated with the idea of 'a woman alone', something Strayed herself struggles with at the beginning. Women are brought up believing that they're damsels in distress in even the most common of situations. We're told not to go out at night. We can't trust members of our own species. So the idea of a female – and what's more of a young female – on her own, in the wilderness, for over a hundred days, is incomprehensible.

I wouldn't say that she's not vulnerable; in fact, Strayed frequently demonstrates fear and there are a few close calls, but most of the time the dangers she's exposed to are equal for men or women. The Pacific Crest Trail doesn't care about your gender if it's going to kill you from pneumonia, or exhaustion, or by bear. She continually exceeds her fellow hikers', companions and her own expectations to gain the trail name 'Queen of the PCT'.

What's more wonderful, is Strayed's underlying commitment to writing. No matter what else changes about Strayed is the fact that she is a writer. Its evidence lies in her carefully chosen quotes from cultural figures such as Churchill, Shakespeare, Joni Mitchell, and Emily Dickinson, her reluctance to part from The Dream of a Common Language and the 'Books burned on the PCT' epilogue – a 'further reading' bibliography for the literary hiker wanting to follow Strayed's novel footsteps. Meanwhile we are reminded that when she finishes the trail, no matter what happens, she will wait tables in the evening, and write in the day.

And I wonder if, for Strayed, the journey would've never been fully complete until it was written down. As with some writers, the physical journey is just the beginning. The literary version –  amended by memory or by fictional licence – is the real journey. Some things cannot be processed as they happen, and instead, processing by way of writing is the real cathartic experience. It certainly seems that way for Strayed.

So I implore anyone who hasn't read Wild yet, don't watch the film first. It's clear from the text that this was never intended to be adapted for Hollywood, although I'm sure Strayed was chuffed to find out Reese Witherspoon was going to play her. This text really is something to be experienced one of two ways. And, I'm sure Cheryl would suggest that 300 pages are much easier to conquer than the PCT.

29 May 2015

"I never feel so much myself as when I’m in a hot bath."


Sylvia Plath ruined baths for me - which is surprising because you'd think out of any household object she'd probably ruin ovens.

In The Bell Jar, the self-absorbed, potentially-autobiographical, protagonist nonchalantly claims that she can recall every bathtub she's ever been in. This absolutely torments me.

Each time I take a bath, I lie in that god-forsaken cream coloured tub and try to count backwards all the bathtubs I can remember being in.

This bath: the family house bath, comforting, echoey and shallow.
My last university house: steep and deep and just a bit dirty.
A hotel in Turkey: excellent acoustics for an album or two.
My first university house: undissolved epsom salts and lukewarm water.

Then it starts to get really difficult.
  • Did that place have a bath or a shower?
  • Do hot-tubs count?
  • What if there was someone else in the bath with me?
I like to think that until the moment Esther Greenwood recalled all of her previous bathtubs, she had led a very sheltered life. Perhaps she'd only ever been in three baths - so actually, her recollection ability isn't that impressive.

The point is, The Bell Jar, is not a novel that leaves no lasting affect. When you finish a book, or a TV show or a particularly good film, sometimes you'll experience that sense of loss. What do I do with my life now?

But The Bell Jar has an incredibly unique effect. You don't feel a passing loss for the story or the characters, instead the bell jar itself begins to form around you. Whether it was there before, and you simply didn't see it, or whether it forms with every passing Plath sentence, The Bell Jar - novel and psychiatric condition - becomes more evident, and harder to get over cope with.
I couldn’t see the point of getting up. I had nothing to look forward to.
With lines like that, I was not the only lit student rendered mildly depressed and bedridden post-Plath.

Esther's bathtub speech comes very early into the novel, and, I believe, is a poignant moment in noticing her internal dislocation. She states that she feels more herself when she's in the tub. And she's right. I also never feel so much Esther Greenwood as when I'm in a hot bath.

16 April 2013

"Is it in yet?": sexualization and the ending in Goblin Market

Christina Rossetti's "children's" poem Goblin Market (1862) is a magical tale about a female society in conjunction with a male-trade marketplace. Or is it? Is it actually a highly sexualised depiction of a microcosm of society with an ending so plain it makes you want to tear out your eyeballs? (Hint it's the latter).

The unavoidable symbol of the mouth, when traced through the poem, highly sexualises Laura and her behaviour. All pleasures are that of the mouth; emphasis is placed on the sense of taste; Lizzie cries to her sister "eat me, drink me, love me". Is sisterly love the kind that can be eaten and drunk from a body? The narrative is laced with homoeroticism - at the very beginning of the narrative we are told the sisters cling to one another "with clasping arms and cautioning lips / with tingling cheeks and finger tips" in a description that begs to evoke coital imagery. 

The sexual relations don't stop there. To save her sister, Lizzie must be effectively "gang-raped". After forbidding her from the male-economy marketplace by refusing to trade her money for their produce they demand a lock of her hair - like her sister gave. Trading her body and using herself as a commodity is the only way to communicate with the Goblins and attempt to participate in the economy. W'hen she refuses, they force themselves upon her and begin to force their "fruits" into her mouth; bombarding her in a grotesquely horrifying scene in which she could be read to remain chaste as she rejects their attempts to penetrate her mouth.

Despite this highly-sexualised portrait, the text seems to be an advocate for female communities without the influence of patriarchy, female education and female freedom. Until the ending. The final passage begins with a stereotypical, conventional: "when both were wives / with children of their own". Despite the conventions that should lead us to accept this ending, resisting readers will be more than taken aback. We've followed the trail of breadcrumbs that led us to believe that these women defy conventions and are outside of the mould - and Rossetti stops us in our tracks. Perhaps it's an advocation of  female lineage or perhaps sexuality - after all marriages need to be consummated and children need to be made - or perhaps it's the interesting twist/fissure for the reader to continue their thinking. Maybe Rossetti simply couldn't end the poem any other way  through constraint by expectations of the period. Either way it's a shame that readers don't get the feminist freedom they so long for, but perhaps it is actually for the better. Prompting discussion and hinting that being a young female can be idyllic, filled with goblins (and sex) but we all grow up and become wives and that's how it should be. It's just up to readers 150 years on to question that.